E46 Fanatics Forum banner
Status
Not open for further replies.

DIY: M54 Timing

1 reading
139K views 44 replies 16 participants last post by  IvanChen  
#1 · (Edited)
Engine Timing

Link to other parts of the project
http://forum.e46fanatics.com/showthread.php?t=899347

Due to the variable nature of the timing, setting it up correctly is a critical task. As many would know, this requires a number of specific BMW tools. The tools have two uses.

1. They get the timing correct.
2. They save a lot of time in the factory environment when doing the timing.

Some of the tools you don't need. Most you do, but they can be easily made if you are half handy in your workshop. I'm in the process of finalising my versions of the tools required, and I'll put them up here when I'm done.

The tools you see here are just the early versions I made up, and look pretty rough. Please don't be concerned about this. The parts of the tools that are touching the engine are actually very accurate.

Before looking at the pieces, here is a bit of an explanation of how the system works.

Each vanos piston is connected to a shaft that has helical splines (grooves) on both the inside and outside. The outside splines are connected to the sprockets (the gears that run on the chains that get turned by the engine). The inner splines are connected to the camshaft. Hence when the shaft is moved in or out by the vanos piston, the relative position of the camshaft and the sprocket changes. Hence variable timing.

Each camshaft has an impulse wheel. This is what is sensed by the camshaft position sensor, and tells the car's computer (DME) the position of that camshaft. If the position sensed is different to what is desired, the DME sends a signal to change the vanos piston, and consequently the camshaft position.

When looking at the gears and chains, there are numerous components, and it can all look a bit daunting. Putting it on wrong is quite difficult. It just won't fit. When everything is in the right order, it all just slides together. When I initially started to pull all this apart, my heart was really beating. It looked that complicated, and this was on an engine that wasn't in a car that I planned to drive tomorrow. If it was on my car at home I would have been sh----ing myself. Having now pulled it all apart, I don't know what all the fuss was about. It's actually pretty simple. That being said, it's a work of art. Some seriously clever engineering in here.

Some of the components are designed to be locked together and stay that way. Others are designed to slide against each other to allow for the variable mechanism. The nuts and springs (they don't look like a normal spring, but that's what they do) are there just to apply the correct pressure between the different plates to allow for the variable movement. They have nothing to do with the timing setup. The only thing you are doing when setting up the timing is getting three components on the exhaust side in the correct place, and then bolting them hard together with the small torx bolts that you see on the exhaust side.

How these three components get to the correct place is a bit complicated, and is why the tools are required. Hopefully the photos will show what I'm talking about.

Initially, here's a couple of photos with the vanos fitted that show what is going on when things move with the variable mechanism.


Image



Image



Before starting on how to do the timing, if you have re-installed the camshafts, or moved them significantly, you should not have had the engine at TDC. It should have been moved to about 30 degrees from TDC to stop any valve piston interference. Before moving the crankshaft to TDC, ensure that the camshafts are moved to the TDC position using the rear tool.

The first part of the timing is getting the camshafts in the correct position down the back.


Image



Image




If you had removed the main sprocket or the intake impulse sensor, here are some photos that will help with their installation. Note these photos are with the camshafts in the TDC position


Image



Image



Image



Image


Be aware that getting all this on needs to be done in the correct order otherwise it won't work.

Image


Now you need to get the engine at top dead center (TDC). You do this by turning the crankshaft at the vibration damper at the front until you see the following. At the same time, you need to look at the camshaft lobes for cylinder 1, and make sure they are in the position shown. As most know, the crankshaft goes around twice for each turn of the camshafts. So it is possible to have the two notches in the correct place on the vibration damper, but the camshafts 180 degrees out. Just turn the crankshaft another full turn if this is the case.


Image



Image




When at TDC, your TDC locking tool should fit in the position shown down the back of the engine into the flywheel. Look at the flywheel photo, and it will show you what it is fitting into.


Image



Image




Now lets look at what is up the front when everything is pulled off. I've laid everything out here in the order that it's going to go on. When pulling it all apart, be careful. You do not want to drop something down in the head. You may not be able to get it back.


Image




When you put everything on, the tools then go on. These are the early versions so don't take too much notice, but the picture and notes hopefully get across what is happening.


Image




When putting the springs on each side, they have to go on the correct way. They should have front marked on them, but if this is worn off, here are some photos that will help.


Image



Image




This photo has the directions on how to put it together, and then do the timing. It's important to put things on in the correct order, and when doing the timing, do it in the correct order. Otherwise it won't work. If you understand what is going on, it should be pretty obvious that it's not working when you do it wrong.

The bentley manual talks about initially torquing the torx bolts to 5nm, and then turning back ½ a turn. This has the torx nuts quite loose. Initially applying 5nm sets everything against each other correctly, but backing them off then allows them to be loose so they can be rotated to the correct position later on. The manual also talks about compressing the springs and then putting on the nuts prior to pushing on the front tool. The problem with this is that the amount of force that is required to push the shafts into the correct position when you put on the front tool is huge. Just have the smallest bit of spring pressure applied. If you have it correct, you won't be able to easily pull or push each splined shaft, but when you put on the front tool, they should be pushed in easily enough as you tighten it to the head. Make sure you have lots of oil applied to the splined shafts. I found this made a lot of difference to how hard it was to push the shafts in with the front tool. Once everything has been tightened (torx bolts 20nm, nuts 10nm), remove the rear tool and flywheel locking tool. Turn the crankshaft over twice so it gets back to TDC, with the camshafts at TDC. Put the flywheel locking tool back in, and then place back on the rear tool. The exhaust side of the rear tool should be perfectly flush with the head. The intake side should be perfectly flush, but is able to have a gap of up to 1mm on the far right hand side.

Image




Some extra photos of the secondary chain tensioner and guide.


Image



Image


Finally, I read on a forum somewhere that someone had allowed their secondary chain tensioner to spring apart, and then couldn't get it back together again. I don't know why this would happen. Here are some photos of it pulled apart. It's very simple to put it back together. Like the main chain tensioner, it also is filled with engine oil pressure, so additional pressure on top of the spring is applied when the engine is running.

Image
 

Attachments

#7 · (Edited)
"When at TDC, your TDC locking tool should fit in the position shown down the back of the engine into the flywheel. Look at the flywheel photo, and it will show you what it is fitting into."

Is this step really necessary? I'm taking apart my engine to set the timing right this time. I was wondering if the engine locking is important and for what reason? If I can skip this step it would save me some time..

EDIT: IT SEEMS I WAS ABLE TO DO THE JOB WITHOUT LOCKING IT. :D
 
#10 ·
Exceedingly good write-up, thank you.

Just one question..... Is the "front tool" (plywood plate) fastened all the way back to the "vanos" surface on the front of the head? Does this then force the splined shafts back to where they need to be?

Do the fronts of the splined shafts have to be in the same plane as the head/vanos mating surface, or is there some form of adjustment screw in your front tool/plate?

Thanks.

BH
 
#11 ·
The plywood plate fastens hard against the vanos mating surface (without the gasket in place) and pushes the splined shafts to their correct position prior to tightening the bolts. There is an adjusting screw for each splined shaft. Each is different, and needs to be set correctly as per the timing tools posts. Have a look there, it will explain all.
 
#14 ·
I'm not sure that the zip ties will do the job. It needs to be pretty accurate. You are better off making the tool. It's not hard. To get to the timing tools posts (there are two) go to the top of this post and click on the "link to other parts of the project". This will take you to the root post for the project which has everything listed. Scroll down and you will see lots of links , including the timing tools. When doing the timing, you will immediately know if it is correct if you don't get a check engine light when driven afterwards. If the timing is incorrect (and there is some fat in the timing setup) the camshafts won't be able to move through their full travel required by the engine's computer, this will be detected by the camshaft position sensors, and hence the CEL. I hope this helps. If you make the tool, let me know how you get on.
 
#16 ·
Just a small clarification please.....Regarding the adjuster bolts on the tioming tool.......

Flat top surface of INTAKE adjuster bolt to be 13mm sunk in the tool/wood, when measured from the flat face of the wood that mates with the head?

Ditto EXHAUST BUT only 3.50mm?

Thank you.

BH
 
#17 ·
I'm in the process of building the front tool and will be using M8x50 bolts with a 1.25mm pitch for the adjuster bolts.

I'm using two slabs/pieces of 3/4" MDF glued and screwed togather and JB welding a nut/washer assembly, sunk in the MDF, for the adjuster bolts to screw through.

That way, the metal nut thread will hopefully be stronger than an MDF thread AND 13mm depth will be 10 turns plus 144 deg, from the surface of the tool.

How accurate are the 13mm and 3.5mm settings? Are they per BMW or per member trial and error?

Thanks.

BH
 
#18 ·
Regard the comments and questions above. When I made the tool, the hole for the adjustable bolts was slightly smaller than the bolts themselves. When I screwed them in they tapped a thread into the MDF. The reason I did this instead of what you are planning is so they didn't move from the adjustment. If you are going to put nuts in there, I would suggest you use nyloc nuts so that after adjusting to the correct depth, there is no chance of them moving. The threads don't need to be very strong. When you bolt the tool to the head, there isn't a lot of force required to push in the splined shafts. If there is, you have the spring nuts or the torx bolts on too tight for the adjustment. The splined shafts should easily push in when you evenly bolt the tool to the head.
Regards the depths, what you say is correct. The dimensions were kindly given to me by M05 when I asked on the forum. Have a look here for his response.

http://forum.e46fanatics.com/showthread.php?t=902663

Hope this helps
 
#25 ·
M54 timing problem

jjrichar,

Absolutely brilliant, concise, and clear timing article! Love it!:clap:

But what am I doing wrong :banghead:

Engine locked at TDC
Both cams locked
Primary exhaust sprocket arrow aligned perfectly with cyl. Head
Dummy tensioner taking up slack in primary chain.

I am using off the shelf kit for locking engine

BUT here’s the issue.
When I slide on inner spline and splined shaft onto camshaft, there is no way I can screw in the 3 Torx bolts when the splined shaft is pulled out to the correct rig position. The holes are covered?

I notice from your photo and mine, with cams locked, that your master key and mine on the camshafts seem to be in a different angular position? Is that possible?
If my master spline was like yours, I reckon that would work for me. But surely the camshaft is a one piece forged unit?

If you have the time, would love to hear your thoughts.

This my first post on this forum, and will attempt to upload photos.

Best regards,

Zappamoon
 

Attachments

#26 · (Edited)
Refer to my OP.

From where you have it in your 1st photo, now fit the inner spline. It needs to be flush with the main sprocket behind (it's not in your photo). Turn the inner spline so the wide spline is sitting at the 12 o'clock, and is in the same position of the wide spline on the camshaft end (which you have in your photo).

Now get the splined shaft and fit it. You should be able to see the rivet in the splined shaft that goes where the wide splines are on the cam shaft end and inner spline. It will take a bit of a wiggle due to it being a tight fit. Push in the splined shaft about half way and you should see the moons align.
 
#27 ·
Thanks for the quick reply.
Your OP is very clear, step by step instructions, and easy to follow.

As you can see from photos, assembled loosely as per your instructions. But with splined shaft pulled fwd to contact rig plate, no way 3 torx bolts can be inserted.

Only way can to see full thread for tox bolts is when splined shaft is pushed fully in which rotates inner spline anti clockwise to expose holes. Naturally with torx now installed impossible to pull splined shaft out due contact with 3 torx!

I am seriously at a loss what is going wrong here!

If arrow on primary exhaust sprocket is lined up with head, and camshaft locked, why is it not possible to rig the exhaust side?
 

Attachments

#28 ·
I do notice something strange.

From your photo of locked exhaust camshaft, if you take a line through master spline and center of camshaft, it is perpendicular to lower flange.

My locked camshaft shows offset clockwise from perpendicular???

If mine was like yours, then everything would line up, and torx would fit, and splined shaft would extend to hit rig plate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.